3D Modeling of Lacus Mortis Pit Crater with Presumed Interior Tube Structure
3D Modeling of Lacus Mortis Pit Crater with Presumed Interior Tube Structure
Journal of Astronomy and Space Sciences. 2015. Jun, 32(2): 113-120
Copyright © 2015, The Korean Space Science Society
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License ( which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
  • Received : March 03, 2015
  • Accepted : May 22, 2015
  • Published : June 15, 2015
Export by style
Cited by
About the Authors
Ik-Seon, Hong
Department of Astronomy, Space Science and Geology, Chungnam National University, Daejeon 305-764, Korea
Yu, Yi
Department of Astronomy, Space Science and Geology, Chungnam National University, Daejeon 305-764, Korea
Jaehyung, Yu
Department of Astronomy, Space Science and Geology, Chungnam National University, Daejeon 305-764, Korea
Junichi, Haruyama
2 Department of Solar System Sciences, Institute of Space and Aeronautical Science, Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency, Kanagawa 252-5210, Japan

When humans explore the Moon, lunar caves will be an ideal base to provide a shelter from the hazards of radiation, meteorite impact, and extreme diurnal temperature differences. In order to ascertain the existence of caves on the Moon, it is best to visit the Moon in person. The Google Lunar X Prize(GLXP) competition started recently to attempt lunar exploration missions. Ones of those groups competing, plan to land on a pit of Lacus Mortis and determine the existence of a cave inside this pit. In this pit, there is a ramp from the entrance down to the inside of the pit, which enables a rover to approach the inner region of the pit. In this study, under the assumption of the existence of a cave in this pit, a 3D model was developed based on the optical image data. Since this model simulates the actual terrain, the rendering of the model agrees well with the image data. Furthermore, the 3D printing of this model will enable more rigorous investigations and also could be used to publicize lunar exploration missions with ease.
The lava tubes of the Moon, which were formed by active lava in the past ( Oberbeck 1971 ; Greeley 1971a , 1971b ; Cruikshank & Wood 1972 ; Head 1976 ), are appropriate for a human base on the Moon ( Horz 1985 ; Coombs & Hawke 1992 ). Since lava tubes are located below the lunar surface, they protect humans from high energy particles such as cosmic rays without any special shielding equipment, thus avoiding radiation damage ( Angelis et al. 2002 ). Also, lava tubes protect humans from physical impact such as those from meteorites. Since lava tubes are sealed, except for the entrance, the atmosphere is so thin that the conservation of temperature is excellent compared to the lunar surface where there is an extreme diurnal temperature difference.
In previous studies, several places presumed to be the entrances of caves were discovered in the Moon and Mars ( Haruyama et al. 2009 , 2010 , 2011 ; Cushing et al. 2007 ; Cushing 2012 ; Jung et al. 2014 ). The shapes of these places are similar to the “sink hole” of earth and they have a slightly larger space inside the entrance. Moreover, about 200 pit-looking places, which are known as pit craters (abbreviated to pits), have been discovered and these can be candidates of caves. The pits are found in the regions of the lunar sea and in places that experienced melting due to meteorite impact ( Robinson et al. 2012 ; Wagner & Robinson 2014 ). Hong et al. (2014) showed that those pits could be entrances of caves through comparing those pits to the actual cave entrance of the Earth.
The Google Lunar X Prize (GLXP) project is a public competition that is planning to explore the Moon using a rover. Among those competitors, Astrobotic Technology Inc. and HAKUTO Team each plan to explore a pit using a rover ( Huber et al. 2014 ; Britton et al. 2015 ). For both teams, the target landing site is a pit of Lacus Mortis. In this pit, there is a ramp down to the bottom of the crater. Thus, it is believed that the rover could approach the inside of the pit. Although there was a report insisting no evidence of cave entrance structure inside this pit ( Wagner & Robinson 2014 ), all the image data of this pit are shadowed to some portion, the complete shape of pit is not possible to identify. Thus, it is arguable whether there is no inner space.
In this study, a 3D model of the pit in Lacus Mortis was built based on the topographical information obtained from the optical image data of this pit.
- 2.1 Area of Interest
The region of interest, the Lacus Mortis pit, is located at 44.96°N, 25.61°E of Lacus Mortis ( Fig. 1 ). Lacus Mortis is in a lunar mare region and composed of basalt and has several rilles. The pit is located about 1 km away from Rimae Burg. The rilles are in the form of straight line and seems to be a kind of graben. There are pyroclastic deposits which seem to be an evidence of volcanic activity around the grabens( Schultz 1972 ; Head 1976 ). Those are believed to be evidences of previous magma activity in the interior of the Moon ( Head & Wilson 1993 ) and lava caves may be in existence there ( Greeley 1971b ).
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Location of Lacus Mortis pit. The location of Lacus Mortis in lunar scale (A); the location of pit in the Lacus Mortis (B); detailed look of pit location (C); Rimae Burg locates in the left of the pit in a diagonal line. (LROC ACT-REACT Quick Map:
The pit is oval shaped and the length of the major axis is about 260 m while the length of the minor axis is about 100 m. Also, there is a ramp enabling access to the inside of the pit ( Fig. 2 ).
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Lacus Mortis pit morphology. Image ID is M126759036L. There is a ramp in the east of the pit to enable access to the interior of the pit. (Image URL:
- 2.2 Data
For this study, the optical image data of the Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter Camera (LROC) from the Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter (LRO) were used. The LROC consists of two cameras; Wide Angle Camera (WAC) and Narrow Angle Camera (NAC). The Narrow Angle Camera (NAC) has a maximum resolution of 0.5 m/pixel and is suitable for analyzing the topography of the lunar surface. The other information of NAC is listed in Table 1 .
LROC/NAC specification.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
LROC/NAC specification.
22 images of Lacus Mortis pit are available up to this time and most of them have similar incident angle and emission angle. For this study, 3 of them were selected which seemed to be a best shot and showing different incident and emission angles. The information of 22 images is shown in Table 2 , and the 3 images selected are shown in Fig. 3 .
Information of Lacus Mortis pit images.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Information of Lacus Mortis pit images.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
The images selected for this study. The structure of the pit can be recognized according to viewing angle due to different emission angle. Image IDs are A: M126759036L, B: M1136377273R, C: M1105701957R.
- 2.3 Method
The detailed information necessary to build a 3D model is obtained by analyzing the NAC image data. It is assumed that there is space of a cave across the eastern slope of the pit ( Fig. 4 ). Since the southern shape of the pit could not be identified due to shadows and the interior space of the pit showed be assumed to take any form until the actual exploration on foot and the small shadow in the northern side also indicates that there is a ramp alongside the wall of the pit, it is considered that this ramp could be an entrance to the inside of the pit. Also, since the collapsed ceiling materials covered the floor of the pit, it is assumed that the entrance of the cave was buried or the size of the entrance is much smaller compared to the thickness of ceiling. Thus, the entrance is set to have a small size. Moreover, the big size pits (about 100 m in diameter) discovered up to the present time may have some inner space inside the pit that can be considered suitable for an outpost once the space is excavated slightly more. The existence of inner space is confirmed through the incidence angle of the sun and the emission angle of the satellite. Incidence angle is angle between solar ray incident and normal of planetary surface, and emission angle is angle between satellite camera and normal of planetary surface. Also, there are a few grabens such as Rimae Burg, it is likely that there might be lava tubes below these grabens ( Greeley 1971b ). Since the pit is not far away from the graben, if there is a lava tube below the surface, the pit could serve as an entrance to this cave. In addition, Astrobotic Technology Inc. and HAKUTO team of GLXP plan to land a rover on this site because there is a ramp on which a wheeled rover could approach the inside of the pit without additional equipment. It looks like the ramp was formed by the collapse of the ceiling, and if we go down the ramp, it is possible to reach the bottom of the pit and explore the inner space. Thus, we have surmised that there is some inner space.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
The conceptual illustration of the inside of Lacus Mortis pit; a cave across the eastern slope of the pit is assumed.
The information necessary to build a model is the length of the major axis, the length of the minor axis, the depth of the pit, the length of the ramp, and the thickness of the crust comprising the ceiling. The information is obtained using the conventional method of measuring the pixel size of various geometrical elements based on the resolution information of image data ( Fig. 5 ). In order to calculate the depth, the end point of the ramp is assumed to be the bottom and the length of the shadow is measured using the following equation ( Haruyama et al. 2009 ):
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Estimated result structure information and sectional view about major axis of Lacus Mortis pit.
D = L /tan( i )
where D is the depth, L is the length of shadow, and i is the incident angle of the sun. The length of the slope is estimated using a simple trigonometric ratio based on the endpoint of the slope, the starting point of the slope, and the depth obtained above. Since it is difficult to find a clear boundary of the ceiling due to the emission angle of the satellite, the thickness of the crust comprising the ceiling is estimated using the trigonometric ratio between the emission angle and the top layer of the crust. The angle of inclination determined based on the trigonometric ratio is 30 degrees, which is consistent with the angle of repose (30 ~ 45 degrees) formed when pebble, sand, or soil pileup naturally. In a real pit, however, the local inclination, rather than the overall inclination, changes according to the distribution of big rocks.
The 3D model rendering was made using 3DS MAX from Autodesk Inc. on a scale of 2000:1. The length of the internal cave in the cross sectional view is 8.6 cm and the height of the internal cave is 3.75 cm. Also, a little bit of tolerance is allowed in each interval of the cave. The reason why the cave is not in a cylindrical shape is due to the assumption that the cave was originally cylindrical, but gradually, the crust material of the ceiling collapsed down to pile up and fill the lower part of the cylinder. If the model covers a larger region that is not limited to the pit, the internal cave will start to have a cylindrical shape that is gradually moving away from the pit.
Each dimension of the model is as follows: the length of the major axis is 18 cm, the length of the minor axis is 5 cm, the depth at the endpoint of ramp is 6.45 cm, and the thickness of the crust at the ceiling is 2.45 cm. There is an unobservable area due to shadow, even when the time of the NAC image data is different. In this case, it was assumed that the model was symmetrical relative to the major axis, and the model was also displayed in various perspectives ( Figs. 6 and 7 ). Also, mesh smooth filtering was applied to express curvatures.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Wireframe image of 3D model. (A) indicates a sectional view against the major axis and takes similar shape shown in Fig. 5. (B) represents a sectional view against the minor axis and shows the placement of the cave. (C) shows a floor plan and shows the shape of the pit and the internal cave. (D) is an aeroview of the model and shows entire shape of the model.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
3D model rendering images of Lacus Mortis pit. (A) is a sectional view against the minor axis and shows the structure of the cave at a glance. (B) shows the shape of the pit. (C) shows an aeroview of the pit and shows the entire shape of the pit. (D) and (E) show the interior of the pit in different angles.
The 3D model built was compared with the NAC image data to find any similarities out similarity with the actual pit. When the viewpoint was set to be consistent with the viewpoint image that resulted from the emission angle of the satellite, it was found that the actual topography was rendered somewhat closely ( Fig. 8 ).
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Comparison of LROC/NAC image and 3D model image. 3D model is appropriate match to 2D optical image.
A 3D model was built using the NAC image data of LROC. We assumed that there was a cave in the inside pit based on the existence of graben around the pit and the fact that the bottom area is bigger than the entrance. It was also likely that there are lava tubes below the graben. In spite of this assumption, since the goal was to render actual topography, the model was quite close in achieving the goal.
One of the benefits of this model is that it is based on a computer graphic tool and allows for changes in viewpoint with ease. Hence, we can observe various features of the topography from many viewpoints. Therefore, the observation can be made from a lunar surface viewpoint rather than a satellite viewpoint which can be of great help in pre-planning the rover mission prior to its operation. While this model lacks precision as it cannot render rocks, small hills, and texture of topography, this kind of precision is of little significance in the view of the structure. Therefore, those details can be neglected.
It has been predicted that lunar caves exist, which could serve as a lunar base. A pit was also discovered recently to be a candidate of cave. In order to ascertain the existence of tube-shaped caves inside a pit, it is best to visit the place in person. However, there has been no human mission since the Apollo mission. Thus, there was no way to determine this. Recently, the X Prize foundation and Google Inc. are working together to create the Google Lunar X Prize, which promotes private-funded missions of lunar landings independent of government or research institutes. Ones of the competitors of this project, Astrobotic Technology Inc. and HAKUTO team, decided to have the landing site on the pit of Lacus Mortis, making it a perfect chance to find out if there is a cave inside the pit through direct observation.
In this research, the structure of the Lacus Mortis pit, which is a target landing site of Astrobotic Technology Inc. and HAKUTO team, was investigated and a 3D model was developed. In spite of the assumption that there is a cave inside the pit, the shape of the model is quite consistent with the satellite image data. Moreover, this model allows for various viewpoints. Thus, a lunar surface viewpoint enables us to determine the topography and to have provisions on how to operate an actual rover. In addition, the 3D printing of this model will enable intuitive analysis and also could be used as a convenient tool to publicize lunar exploration missions.
This research was supported by the National Nuclear R&D Program through the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) grant funded by the Korean government (MSIP) (2014M2B2A9032253) and by the Space Core Technology Development Program through the Ministry of Education, Science, and Technology (MEST) (2012M1A3A3A02033496).
Britton N , Yoshida K , Walker J , Nagatani K , Taylor G , Mejias L , Corke P , Roberts J 2015 Lunar Micro Rover Design for Exploration through Virtual Reality Tele-operation, Field and Service Robotics Springer International Publishing Switzerland 259 - 272
Coombs CR , Hawke BR , Mendell W. W. 1992 A search for intact lava tubes on the Moon: Possible lunar base habitats Lunar and Planetary Institute Houston The Second Conference on Lunar Bases and Space Activities of the 21st Century 219 - 229
Cruikshank DP , Wood CA 1972 Lunar rilles and Hawaiian volcanic features: Possible analogues The Moon 3 412 - 447    DOI : 10.1007/BF00562463
Cushing GE , Titus TN , Wynne J.J , Christensen PR 2007 THEMIS observes possible cave skylights on Mars Geophys. Res. Lett. 34 L17201 -    DOI : 10.1029/2007GL030709
Cushing GE 2012 Candidate cave entrances on Mars J. Cave Karst Stud. 74 33 - 47    DOI : 10.4311/2010EX0167R
De Angelis G , Wilson JW , Clowdsley MS , Nealy JE , Humes DH 2002 Lunar lava tubes radiation safety analysis J. Radiat. Res. 43 41 - 45    DOI : 10.1269/jrr.43.S41
Greeley R 1971 Lava tubes and channels in the lunar Marius Hills The Moon 3 289 - 314    DOI : 10.1007/BF00561842
Greeley R 1971 Observations of actively forming lava tubes and associated structures Hawaii, Mod. Geol. 2 207 - 223
Haruyama J , Hioki K , Shirao M , Morota T , Hiesinger H 2009 Possible lunar lava tube skylight observed by SELENE cameras Geophys. Res. Lett. 36 L21206 -    DOI : 10.1029/2009GL040635
Haruyama J , Hara S , Hioki K , Morota T , Yokota Y New Discoveries of Lunar Holes in Mare Tranquillitatis and Mare Ingenii 41st Lunar and Planetary Science Conference Houston, TX 1-5 Mar 2010
Haruyama J , Sawai S , Mizuno T , Yoshimitsu T , Fukuda S Exploration of Lunar Holes, Possible Skylights of Underlying Lava Tubes, by Smart Lander for Investigating Moon (SLIM) 28th International Symposium on Space Technology and Science Okinawa, Japan 5-12 June 2011    DOI : 10.2322/tastj.10.Pk_7
Head JW 1976 Lunar volcanism in space and time Rev. Geophys. 14 265 - 300    DOI : 10.1029/RG014i002p00265
Head JW , Wilson L 1993 Lunar graben formation due to nearsurface deformation accompanying dike emplacement Planet. Space Sci. 41 719 - 727    DOI : 10.1016/0032-0633(93)90114-H
Hong IS , Yi Y , Kim E 2014 Lunar Pit Craters Presumed to be the Entrances of Lava Caves by Analogy to the Earth Lava Tube Pits J. Astron. Space Sci. 31 131 - 140    DOI : 10.5140/JASS.2014.31.2.131
Horz F , Mendell W. W. 1985 Lunar bases and space activities of the 21st century Lunar and Planetary Institute Houston Lava Tubes: Potential Shelters for Habitats 405 - 412
Huber SA , Hendrickson DB , Jones HL , Thornton JP , Whittaker WL Astrobotic Technology: Planetary Pits and Caves for Science and Exploration Annual Meeting of Lunar Exploration Analysis Group Laurel, MD 22-24 Oct 2014
Jung J , Yi Y , Kim E 2014 Identification of Martian Cave Skylights Using the Temperature Change During Day and Night J. Astron. Space Sci. 31 141 - 144    DOI : 10.5140/JASS.2014.31.2.141
Oberbeck VR 1971 Laboratory simulation of impact cratering with high explosives J. Geophys. Res. 76 5732 - 5749    DOI : 10.1029/JB076i023p05732
Robinson MS , Ashley JW , Boyd AK , Wagner RV , Speyerer EJ 2012 Confirmation of sublunarean voids and thin layering in mare deposits Planet. Space Sci. 69 18 - 27    DOI : 10.1016/j.pss.2012.05.008
Schultz PH 1972 Moon Morphology University of Texas Press Houston
Wagner RV , Robinson MS 2014 Distribution, formation mechanism, and significance of lunar pits Icarus 237 52 - 60    DOI : 10.1016/j.icarus.2014.04.002